The Illegal Visits of Foreign Citizens to the Occupied Crimea in September 2017 - the Monitoring Results.

By Tetyana GUCHAKOVA
BSNews, Black Sea Institute of Strategic Studies, Maidan of Foreign Affairs

Translated by Tetyana PUCHKOVA

More than any other place in Russia, the occupied Crimea has a typical Soviet — now, typical Russian — conflicting attitude towards foreigners. On the one hand, the country is completely surrounded by enemies wanting death to the young Soviet state the great Russia who is rising from its knees. On the other, every traveler from the hated West who Russia manages to lure to the annexed territory, becomes a cherished guest and ally whose visit invariably means a top-notch reception and show off, and of course, is used for the maximum propaganda effect.

The latter conveniently manages to utilize even the sanctions and investment bans in the occupied Crimea by claiming the need to «protect the guests from the sanctions» that allows to conceal the real number of foreign visitors. For example, at a press conference in September, the permanent representative of the "Republic of Crimea" with the President of the Russian Federation, Georgy Muradov, said that "over the past year and a half over a hundred foreign delegations, including prominent public and political figures and parliamentarians, visited Crimea.»

The Russian official stated the purpose of working with foreigners very openly, stating that visits to Crimea by foreign politicians, businessmen and public and state figures demonstrate "the collapse of plans for the international isolation of the peninsula»:"

«That influences the formation of the international, in particular, European public opinion that increasingly understands that Crimea has returned home and feels absolutely comfortable and that the rights of people in Crimea are respected. We need to remove this topic from the agenda and develop normal relations between the countries of Europe and the Russian Federation.»

The occupiers regularly organize events that can be called "international" and used for the statements about the «breaking the blockade». In September those included:

• Andalusia Days in Crimea
• "GIT Crimea 2017" International Tournament on mixed martial arts
• Live In Blue Bay IXth International Open Air Jazz Festival
• Eurasian Bridge IInd Yalta International Film Festival
• Crimea Military-Historical Festival
• International Crimean Traumatology Conference
• Opera and Cinema gala concert
• Transmission Festival

The Maidan of Foreign Affairs monitoring group has identified 37 foreign — non-Russian — violators of the occupied territory regime in September 2017. This is not an exhaustive list, as the identification process continues and the blacklist will be added to.

The record number of September violators — seven visitors — was set by was France. Two of them played foreign observers at the occupied Sevastopol «elections,» while two more participated in the Crimean military-historical festival on the Fedyukhin heights near Sevastopol, the French director Patrick Kazal sat on the jury of the Eurasian Bridge film festival in the occupied Yalta, professor Patrick Bruno of the French School of Protocol of International Relations visited the Crimean Federal University and the head of the Department of Traumatology of the University Hospital in Strasbourg, Gilbert Taglane, participated in the conference Crimean Traumatology Conference.

Four offenders came from Italy, Germany and Spain.

As always, the lion's share of visitors from Germany came from various "friendship societies" actively supported there by Russia. The occupation media reports a September visit to Yalta of a group of 12 organized by the public organization Baden-Baden-Yalta. To date, the monitoring group has identified two of the participants: the visit organizer, the Baden-Baden-Yalta’s chairman Gerhard El and his wife, Uta El. In addition, a German boxer and the head of the the University of Giessen’s Department of Trauma Surgery were also spotted among the perpetrators from Germany.

The Italian list of September violators includes a jazz vocalist, a wine expert, a medical faculty of the University of San Pablo-CEU in Boadilla del Monte, the director of the PFI company and a journalist who actually visited the occupied peninsula in August, but were mentioned in publications in September.

Spain has «presented» the occupied territory with the President of the National Assembly of Andalusia who participated in the "Andalusia Days in the Crimea", a professor of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology of the University of San Pablo-CEU Medical School, a composer of Russian origin and a jazz singer, also of Russian origin, Maria Niankina with the romantic stage name Masha Ocean (the visit was a great «professional success" for the singer who in Malaga mostly sings in bars).

Three more violators came from the UK, the Netherlands and China each, two from Sweden and Kyrgyzstan each and one from Austria, Finland, Estonia, Uzbekistan and South Korea each.

	Вильгельм Отт / Wilhelm Ott	Austria	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Гарет Джонс / Gareth Jones / Garet Dzhons	UK	film director, Head of the jury of the Eurasian Bridge IInd Yalta International Film Festival in the occupied Yalta
	Кристиан Бернс / Christian Anthony Burns / Kristian Berns	UK	vocalist, Transmission Festival (Simferopol) participant
	Рой Янг / Roy Young	UK	musician, Live In Blue Bay Jazz Festival (Koktebel) participant
	Жерард Эль / Герхард Эль / Gerhard Ell	Germany	Head of the Badan-Baden-Yalta NGO, organizer of the Yalta visit of 12 Baden-Baden residents, honorary resident of Yalta
	Ута Эль / Uta Ell	Germany	Spouse of the Head of the Badan-Baden-Yalta NGO, visited Crimea as part of the group
	Даниэль Деррер / Daniel Dörrer / Daniel Dyorrer	Germany	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Рейнхард Шнеттлер / Reinhard Schnettler	Germany	head of the Department of Trauma Surgery of the University of Giessen, Medical Center of the University of Giessen and Marburg, International Crimean Traumatology Conference participant
	Юрий Чугуев / Yuri Chuguyev	Spain	Spanish composer of Russian origin, Andalusia Days in Crimea participant
	Педро Альтамирано / Pedro Ignacio Altamirano Macarrón / Pedro Altamirano	Spain	the President of the National Assembly of Andalusia, Andalusia Days in Crimea participant
	Masha Ocean / Мария Нянькина / Maria Nyankina	Spain	jazz singer, Opera and Cinema gala concert participant
	Франциско Луис Форриол Кампос / Francisco Luis Forriol Campos	Spain	a medical faculty of the University of San Pablo-CEU in Boadilla del Monte (Madrid), International Crimea Traumatology Conference participant
	Марко Риццини / Marco Rizzini	Italy	journalist, stayed in Crimea for a week in August 2017
	Фабио Лепоре / Fabio Lepore	Italy	jazz vocalist, Live In Blue Bay Jazz Festival (Koktebel) participant
	Клаудио Пичини / Claudio Piccini	Italy	Head of the PFI company, a Sodium hypochlorite plant equipment supplier, visited the occupied Sevastopol
	Лука Марони / Luca Maroni / Luka Maroni	Italy	wine expert, visited the wineries of the occupied Crimea
	Ильяз Абдуллаев/ Ilyaz Abdullayev	Kyrgyzstan	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Саймонкул Насыров/ Saimonkul Nasyrov	Kyrgyzstan	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Ли Тиен-Хсин / Li Tien-Hsin + другие (попытаться идентифицировать)	China	Vice President of the University of WuFeng, visited and signed a cooperation agreement with the CFU
	Tsai Hung-Jung	China	a University of WuFeng representative, visited CFU in the occupied Simferopol
	Li Chung-Hsin Ha	China	a University of WuFeng representative, visited CFU in the occupied Simferopol
	Анатолий Смирнов / Tolik Smirnoff	Netherlands	a Netherlands citizen of Russian origin, member of the Mama’s Bad Boys RB band, Live In Blue Bay Jazz Festival (Koktebel) participant
	Ламар "Кинг Би" Чейс / Lamar ‘King Bee’ Chase	US, Netherlands	member of the Mama’s Bad Boys RB band, Live In Blue Bay Jazz Festival (Koktebel) participant
	Отис Рахим Хорнсби / Otis Rahim Hornesby	US, Netherlands	member of the Mama’s Bad Boys RB band, Live In Blue Bay Jazz Festival (Koktebel) participant
	Нурсултан Рузибоев /  Nursultan Ruziboyev	Uzbekistan	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Нико Миллинен / Niko Myllynen	Finland	boxer, GIT Crimea 2017 International Tournament on mixed martial arts participant
	Патрик Брюно / Patrick Brunot	France	professor of HEIP (Paris), visited CFU in the occupied Simferopol
	Тьерри Мариани / Thierry Mariani / Terri Mariani	France	France National Assembly deputy, took part in the occupied Sevastopol ’s «elections» as an «international observer»
	Николя Дюик / Nicolas Dhuicq / Nikolya Dyuik	France	Brian de Chateau mayor, took part in the occupied Sevastopol ’s «elections» as an «international observer»
	Жозеф Рюффье / Joseph Ruffier	France	Crimea Military-Historical Festival (Sevastopol) participant
	Патрик Казаль	France	film director, jury member of the Eurasian Bridge IInd Yalta International Film Festival in the occupied Yalta
	Мишель Вибер / Michel Vibert	France	Crimea Military-Historical Festival (Sevastopol) participant
	Жильбер Таглан/ Gilbert Taglang	France	head of the Department of Traumatology of the University Hospital in Strasbourg, Gilbert Taglane, Crimean Traumatology Conference participant
	Ян Бернадотт / Carl-Johan (Jan) Gustaf Wilhelm Bernadotte / Yan Bernadott	Sweden	count of Wisborg, wine expert and sommelier, visited the wineries of the occupied Crimea
	Гунилла Бернадотт/ Gunnila Bernadotte	Sweden	spouse of Carl-Johan (Jan) Gustaf Wilhelm Bernadotte, visited the wineries of the occupied Crimea
	Рейн Мюллерсон/ Rein Müllerson	Estonia	professor, School of Governance, Law and Society of the Tallinn University, visited the occupied Crimea, participated in a Sputnik in Crimea radio-program
	Ли Бохун Гамильтон / H. E. Hamilton B. Dr.Lee	South Korea	Chairman of the Retag GlobalInvest international investment fund, in Crimea signed a cooperation agreement with the Crimea Development Corporation

The so much needed for the invaders sense of constant presence of foreigners in Crimea is maintained in the Russian mass media not only by numerous publications about the visits, but also by the repetitive announcements of future visits long in advance.

For example, the November Forum of the Friends of Crimea was repeatedly reported by the occupation media in September, the also November Open Crimea forum — in August and the Yalta International Economic Forum held in the spring does not disappear from the media all year round.

Some visits, however, remain just that — announcements. For instance, every month starting with February 2015, the visit of the UEFA delegation to Crimea was announced for different dates. And this September the European football functionaries were still expected in Crimea, but no avail…

Many other western guests are also not in a hurry to visit. In September, Yalta officials complained that «due to the pressure of Ukraine" six tourists from Germany's Baden-Baden had decided not to come.

* * *

The monitoring of the violations of international sanctions against Russia and the legal regime of the temporarily occupied territory of Crimea is supported by the European program initiative of the "Renaissance" International Fund. The views of the authors do not necessarily reflect the position of the position of the "Renaissance" International Fund.